Pay Your Staff More: Why £3 an Hour Could Free You From Your Business

Pay Your Staff More: Why £3 an Hour Could Free You From Your Business

17 November 2026

What if £3 an hour is the thing stopping you stepping away from your business? It sounds daft, but I see it all the time. Owners refuse to pay their staff more, then wonder why they can’t find anyone good.

In the latest episode of Busy is Bullsh*t, I tell the story of a client who nearly turned down a superstar over £3 an hour. I also share the three things I’d do differently if I started another trade business tomorrow.

Prefer your podcast app? Listen to Busy is Bullsh*t on Spotify.

The short answer: should you pay your staff more? For the right person, yes. An extra £3 an hour is £120 a week, or about £480 a month. Add it to your prices and the customer pays for it, while you get a team leader who takes a whole team off your hands.

Two builders working on scaffolding: pay your staff more and keep your best tradesmen

Why recruitment is the hardest part of growing a trade business

I’ve lost count of the owners who tell me you can’t get good guys any more. The young ones don’t want to work, and the ones you can get are useless. I get it, because it took me years to figure out recruitment. Believe me, I had some absolute weapons in my business.

One afternoon I popped into the office and my project manager was on the phone to a fitter. It was half two, and the fitter needed another eight square metres of monoblock. No problem, I said. We’ll order it now and it’ll be on site first thing tomorrow, so just carry on laying.

His answer? He couldn’t carry on laying, because he’d run out of block. He’d been laying off that pallet for over an hour, and at no point did he look at what was left and think, I’d better order more.

That’s the kind of thing you deal with when you hire the wrong people. In fact, if I’m honest, dealing with that day in, day out was the main reason I sold my driveway company. So when you do find someone good, it’s worth paying your staff more to keep them.

The £3 an hour conversation that nearly cost a client a superstar

A few months ago, a client of mine told me about a tradesman he wanted to hire. He’s a joiner, so let’s call him John. The tradesman was brilliant. He lived locally, he was great at his job and he’d run his own business, so he understood ordering materials and managing staff.

John interviewed him and came back with bad news. He wasn’t taking him on. Why? Because the guy wanted £24 an hour, and John only paid £21.

So I broke it down for him. £3 an hour over a 40-hour week is £120 a week. Then I asked him a question. If I could take away your installation headaches, manage one of your teams, order the materials and run the jobs for £120 a week, would you take it?

Of course he would. Well, that’s all this guy was asking for. John took him on in the end. He’s an absolute superstar, and he now runs that team.

Will you lose jobs if you pay your staff more?

This is the worry I hear most. But think about it. John does kitchens, bathrooms, windows and doors. His average job is around £18,000, so let’s be really cautious and call it £10,000.

Do you honestly think a customer says no to a £10,000 job because it’s now £10,120? Of course not. In fact, John added the extra cost to his price list, and his conversion rate didn’t move one bit.

Extra per hour Per week (40 hours) Per month (4 weeks) On a one-week £10,000 job
£1 £40 £160 0.4%
£3 £120 £480 1.2%
£5 £200 £800 2%
£9 (£21 up to £30) £360 £1,440 3.6%

Now, if you’re a sole trader quoting small jobs, £120 can make a difference. However, when you’re pricing £10,000, £20,000 or £30,000 projects, it simply doesn’t.

Why I’d pay my staff more than every competitor

If I started another trade business tomorrow, I’d make sure my team were the best paid in the area. Back then, my lads were paid about the same as my competitors. Next time, I’d be well above them, and the customer would pay for every penny of it.

Why? Because it saves so much grief. When your team are the best paid around, they want to keep their jobs. As a result, they turn up on time, they do the job the way you sold it and they don’t push their luck.

That matters, because you stand in front of a customer and promise certain standards. Then a fitter turns up and decides to do it his way.

One of the best fitters I ever had, Peter, did exactly that in his first month. We dug our driveways down to 300mm, laid a geotextile fabric and compacted the Type 1 in two layers. When I visited his site, it was nowhere near 300mm, there was no fabric and it was all in one layer. “That’s just how I do it,” he said.

I even called our Marshalls rep to prove the point. He did it our way in the end, and he turned out to be brilliant. But there’s a lesson there too. Back then, I had no installation guides and no proper chat before a new fitter started. If you’re building that side of things, read how to hire employees you can trust.

The bad apple who’s running your business

Some of you have a staff member who is actually running your company. He tells you what time he’s finishing. He turns up late, leaves early and talks to the team, customers or even you like rubbish. But he’s good at his job, so he gets away with it.

Here’s the test. If you plan your team meetings around one person, he’s running your business. Being willing to pay your staff more gives you a better pool of people, and that gives you the confidence to replace him.

Myth: pay one of your staff more and they’ll all want a rise

First of all, wages should be confidential. Even so, people talk in vans, and if your existing team find out, that’s a conversation you’ll have to have.

Better still, have it first. Say your current superstar is on £21. Sit him down and explain that you’re bringing in someone at £24. Then set out a clear path. If he can manage staff, speak with clients, order materials and give proper updates by January, he goes up to £24 as well.

Do this in a proper sit-down meeting, not a text or a voice note. Promises made in passing don’t get taken seriously. And if you’re taking on staff for the first time, the gov.uk guide to employing staff covers the legal basics.

Finally, when you find a real all-rounder, pay them properly. Honestly, I’d give them £30 an hour, because people like that are so rare.

The other two things I’d do differently

Paying my staff more is only one of the three things I’d change. The other two cost very little.

  1. Build a proper website. Your customers go on Google when they want a new kitchen, roof or driveway. So I’d build an all-singing, all-dancing website, because for a trade business your website matters far more than mine does for Tradecoach.
  2. Build a brand people talk about. I’d make sure people talked about my business around the coffee table, at work and over the garden fence. My business coach once told me the only person who cares about your company name and logo is you. He was right.

Here’s a quick win on that second point. Look at any flyer. Most put the logo in the top left, which is exactly where people look first. You’ve got a split second to grab attention, so put your strongest promise there instead. I swapped my logo for our guarantee, and it made a real difference.

For the bigger picture on growing past this stage, read why trade businesses stall between £450k and £1m.

FAQs: should you pay your staff more?

How much more should I pay a good tradesman?

Enough to be clearly the best paid in your area for that role. For a proven team leader, an extra £3 an hour is usually the difference. For a true all-rounder who manages staff, customers and materials, I’d happily go to £30 an hour, because the customer covers it.

Will paying my staff more make my prices uncompetitive?

Not on bigger jobs. An extra £120 a week on a £10,000 job is about 1%. My client added it to his price list and his conversion rate didn’t change. If you can’t sell a job for £120 more, look at your sales and lead generation, not your wages.

What if my other staff find out what the new guy earns?

Keep wages confidential, but be ready for the conversation. Give your existing best people a clear path to the same rate, with the extra responsibilities they need to take on and a date to hit it by. Then put it in writing and review it with them.

How do I stop good tradesmen leaving?

Pay them well above your competitors, give them clear standards and installation guides, and sit down with them regularly. People stay where they feel valued and know exactly what’s expected of them. In my experience, that’s far cheaper than constantly recruiting.

If you take one thing from this episode, make it this: pay your staff more, and put it on the price.

Find out where your business stands

Want to know exactly where your business is stuck? Take the free Business Freedom Assessment. It only takes a few minutes.

And if you’d rather listen, the full episode is on Spotify and Podbean.

© 2026 Tradecoach — Business Coaching for Tradespeople|2 Deer Park Ave, Livingston, EH54 8AF, United Kingdom|Tel: +44 7889 906446|Contact us